Home 

Back to Complaints  

 

 

Manickam

 

Ref No. GoI/RM/Manick-1996-97

 

1.    Name                                  :     Manickam

2.    SC/ST                                 :     SC/Trichy/Madras State

3.    Qualifications                       :     MA

4.    Service                                :     Indian Railway Traffic Service – 1966

------------------------------------------------------------------------------

 

 

A.     Problem Posting               :Chief Commercial Manager, South Central Railway, Secunderabad

                                                Posted – Month & Year  :1992

 

PROBLEM AND DISCRIMINATION

 

Was transferred from North Eastern Railway, Gorakpur, to South Central Railway, Secunderabad in 1992 as CCM.  Was staying alone in Secunderabad as his Family was in Madras, where the Children were staying.  All his Requests for Transfer to South Central Railway, Madras, or posting at Vijayawada in South Central Railway, over night journey away from Madras, were systematically denied.  Mr Manickam was also a serious heart patient, and was advised to undergo an open heart surgery, by the Specialist Doctors, of Railway Hospital, Perambur, Madras.  Both the General Manager South Central Railway, and Chairman – Railway Board Mr Kau, resisted his Transfer.  As a result Mr Manickam died, with a massive Heart Attack, and without any help and uncared for, when he was alone, and his peon was out somewhere.  Even after his Death, lots of Problems were created.  Though he was a Senior Officer in the Senior Administrative Grade of a Joint Secretary, Railway Doctors refused to release his body, on the ground that he had died when he was alone.  Hence there was a considerable delay in shifting his body to Madras where his wife and children were living.

 

REASON :    This was a plain Discrimination.  He was refused the Transfer to Madras, to join his family.  He was not given a Transfer even on Medical Grounds, to undergo by-pass Heart Surgery in Railways’ own specialist Heart Hospital in Madras.  That, even after serving in the far-off Gorakpur.

 

SUSPECTED :  To stop his further promotions, being a Christian SC Dalit.  Further he was known for mobilising, organising and helping SCs&STs, both in their work in Office, and for socio-economic Development in their lives outside.

 

 

 

B.     Problem Posting               :Chief Commercial Manager, Southern Railway, Madras

                                                Posted – Month & Year  :1988

 

PROBLEM AND DISCRIMINATION

 

In 1990, was transferred from Southern Railway, Madras to North Eastern Railway, Gorakpur, as a punishment posting in the same rank as CCM, as he had fallen out with the then General Manger, Mr Narasimhan of Southern Railway.  That even though, Mr Narasimhan himself had never served outside Southern Railway, through out his career.  Yet, he was promoted as General Manager, Southern Railway.  That, even though he was only an Accounts Officer, and he was known for extreme corruption and many criminal activities.  His only Qualifications were, he was a brahmin, related to the crook Mr Venkatraman, who became Vice President and President.  Naturally Mr Narasimhan was very arrogant and vindictive.  And Mr Manickam, being a poor SC, was an easy victim.  And all his representations to cancel the transfer went unheeded, though he was an heart patient, undergoing treatment in Railways’ own specialist Heart Hospital in Perambur, Madras.  He had to stay alone in Gorakpur, as his Family was in Madras, where the Children were studying.  All his Requests for Transfer to Southern Railway, were systematically denied.  At last Mr Manickam was posted to South Central Railway, Secunderabad, where again he had to stay alone till his sudden demise as a result of a massive Heart Attack, and without any help and uncared for, when he was alone, and his peon was out somewhere.

 

REASON :    This was a case of open Harassment and Discrimination.  He was refused the Transfer to Madras, to join his family.  He was not given a Transfer even on Medical Grounds, to undergo by-pass Heart Surgery in Railways’ own specialist Heart Hospital in Madras.  That, even after serving in the far-off Gorakpur.

 

SUSPECTED :  To stop his further promotions, being a Christian SC Dalit.  Further he was known for mobilising, organising and helping SCs&STs, both in their work in Office, and for socio-economic Development in their lives outside.

 

***************